Conventional wisdom dictates that adding more 0° plies in the load-bearing direction of a laminate will increase its stiffness and strength. While this is true for undamaged laminates, the compression strength of laminates with impact damage may not be as straightforward. In this study, compression after impact strengths of relatively thin laminates with 25%, 33% or 50% of plies aligned in the 0° load-bearing direction were measured for three different damage severity levels. Results show that the increase in compression strength of the laminates with a higher percentage of plies in the 0° direction is lessened as impact damage severity increases indicating that a laminate that is stronger in compression when undamaged may not be stronger in compression when impact damage is accounted for.