Face recognition is one of the interpersonal judgements carried out by pedestrians. Road lighting should enhance the visual component of such judgements after dark. This paper presents experiments carried out using two different procedures, identification and perceived recognition, to investigate why earlier studies have led to inconsistent conclusions about the influence of spectral power distribution (SPD) on face recognition. For the identification procedure, two observation durations were employed (1 s and 3 s). The two procedures led to similar conclusions regarding recognition ability at different distances. Review of these and past results suggests that an effect of lamp (SPD) is more likely to be found when the task is difficult, i.e. small size, brief observation and correctly naming the target rather than simply picking a face from a sample.